Making the most of travel rewards requires some understanding of the basic questions, like how much each reward currency is worth. Earning 100,000 points sounds great, but what does that mean in terms of dollars?
To find out, Pointypress performed a comprehensive, data-driven analysis of 15 airlines, seven hotel programs and nine credit card rewards programs. We compared cash and award bookings across many dates and cities to determine how much actual value you can expect to get from any given points or miles.
We added business-class valuations to our airline miles analysis.
We added analysis of seven new airline programs.
We included international data (after excluding it in 2020).
For the hotel and airline valuations, we picked the 75th percentile value, rather than the average or median. This means that for every four searches, we picked the one that offered the highest value. We believe this reflects how travelers shop for award bookings — by comparing cash and point redemptions across several dates.
Consider these values a “baseline” for what you could actually get when using your award currency to book regular trips (i.e., we’re not limiting our search just to travel options where you’d receive outsize value).
If you get our baseline value or more from a given redemption, you’re doing a good job.
Airline and hotel points and miles valuations
Keep in mind that the airline values are based on main cabin economy tickets and exclude premium cabin redemptions. See “Airline business class values” below for more details.
Because transferable credit card points offer more complexity and value range than standard travel rewards, we offer two separate values for each program or card:
Baseline value. This is the promised value from the issuer when using the points to book travel directly with their internal tools, such as using Chase Ultimate Rewards® points to book travel through the Chase travel portal.
Pointypress value. This is a combination of the baseline value and the value of each programs’ highest-value transfer partner (per the table above).
How these values have changed over time
On the whole, airline miles increased slightly in value since last year, with one notable exception (Southwest).
Delta and JetBlue loyalty members can emerge from the COVID-19 pandemic with much more valuable miles than before. Their values climbed to 1.5 cents and 1.5 cents per mile respectively, putting them ahead of the 2021 average value of 1.2 cents per mile and outperforming their legacy carrier competitors, like United and American.
The value of Frontier’s miles more than doubled as well this year, though it still lags behind the value of other full-service airlines’ miles.
Southwest’s devaluation is the big exception this year. After encouraging members the option to convert their travel funds to Rapid Rewards points last year, the airline devalued their points in early 2021, dropping from 1.6 cents per point to 1.5 cents. Southwest is no longer beating out the competition by 0.5 cent or more as it was last year.
Southwest uses dynamic award pricing that correlates with the cash price, so Rapid Rewards members usually know what to expect. Most flyers get about the same value for their points, no matter whether they book a cheap or expensive flight.
In the hotel world, valuations have slightly declined or stayed the same overall. Most hotels’ points slid just 0.1 of a cent since last year and Hyatt remains the most valuable hotel points currency.
Marriott has had the biggest decline during the pandemic. In 2019, the last “normal” year, Marriott had the second highest valuation of 1.2 cents per point. The following year, that valuation dropped to 0.9 cent and this year, it’s sitting at 0.7 cent cent per point. Instead of toward the top of the valuation list, Marriott is now tied for fourth with Best Western. It appears that while the cash prices for Marriott dropped during the pandemic and continue to remain low, the award pricing has not dipped nearly as much.
On the other hand, Radisson’s points valuation has recovered to pre-pandemic levels. The valuation doubled to 0.6 cent this year, matching its 2019 valuation.
Airline business class point values (New this year)
For the first time, we collected data on the value of airline miles when booking business class fares. These values are, generally, much higher than the baseline values described above, in large part because of the high cost of booking these fares with cash.
If you exclusively use your miles to book business class fares, you can use these estimates as a baseline value.
ANA is the clear standout here, offering a whopping 7.4 cents per mile in value when booking business class tickets. Delta falls on the other end of the spectrum, offering only slightly more value when booking business class rather than economy fares.
Note: Airlines such as Southwest and Spirit, which do not offer business class redemptions, are excluded from this analysis.
We collected real-world data on thousands of flights and hotel stays to determine these values.
We compared cash prices to award redemptions for the same flights and rooms. For example, we cross-referenced the cost of flying round-trip from New York to Los Angeles using either cash or award miles. Then, we divided the cost of the cash tickets by the cost of the award tickets to determine a “cent per mile” value for each flight.
These searches were made in May 2021.
Airline valuation methodology
We compared main cabin fares across all airlines, and business class fares across those airlines that offer them. We did not use basic economy fares.
Three of the busiest routes from the airline’s hub.
Three short routes (under 650 miles).
Three mid-length routes (651-1,500 miles).
Two trans-continental routes (over 1,500 miles).
One route from a hub to a small airport.
Ten international routes.
For each airline, we chose three dates for comparison:
Within 15 days of departure.
During peak winter holiday travel (Dec. 22-29).
Hotel valuation methodology
Rates and rooms
For both cash and reward bookings, we selected the lowest-priced refundable room.
We chose five major cities and five midsize cities:
For each hotel chain, we selected brands from three categories: budget, mid-tier and luxury (as determined by our in-house experts). We selected individual hotels from each category in each city, when available.
We selected two timeframes for both cash and reward bookings:
Within 15 days of travel.
Credit card valuation methodology
To determine the value of credit card points, we considered:
The value of these points when used to book travel directly with the credit card’s travel portal.
The value of the airline and hotel points to which these points can be transferred, when applicable (based on the separate analyses above).
The number of top-tier travel transfer partners, as determined by our expert panel.
The overall value is determined as: A weighted average between (1) and (2), with the weight determined by (3). The program with the largest number of high-value partners receives a 100% weight on (2), and a program with zero high-value partners receives a 50% weight on (2).
We selected the 75th percentile value for all data analysis.
How to maximize your rewards
You want a travel credit card that prioritizes what’s important to you. Here are our picks for the best travel credit cards of 2022, including those best for: